Case study · Executive Presence & Leadership · Career Progression

He Was Delivering the Work. Leadership Wasn't Seeing the Impact. Here's What Changed.

Siddharth Gupta, a seasoned finance professional and AVP at Barclays Investment Bank, felt his contribution wasn't translating into recognition. Over about three months we worked on business impact, end-to-end ownership and the confidence to ask questions in leadership conversations.

By Coach Dinesh Kumar. Client details published with permission.

Client
Siddharth Gupta
Role
AVP, Barclays Investment Bank; previously KPMG
Engagement
Approximately three months
Focus
Executive presence, leadership visibility, strategic communication
Outcome
Appraisal rating moved from a typical 2–3 range to 4

The problem: high contribution, limited recognition

He contributed to projects and put in the expected effort, yet felt his work wasn't translating into the recognition and opportunities he deserved. Important projects seemed to go to colleagues with stronger relationships with leadership, and some colleagues were recognised for work where he felt he had done far more.

The diagnosis: delivering work without showing its business impact

At first it looked like workplace favouritism and a lack of recognition. We found something more fundamental: he was delivering work, but not consistently showing its business impact.

When we examined his projects closely, he couldn't always explain their commercial significance, the problems they solved or the value they created for the client. Meanwhile, some colleagues communicated their contributions more clearly and made their impact visible.

The coaching work: from task execution to leadership ownership

  • Understanding business impact, not just completing tasksHe was focused on his own piece of work and wasn't consistently connecting it to larger business objectives. We examined each project through new questions: what problem is this actually solving for the client, what is the business value of solving it, and how much time or operational effort does it save? These questions changed his view of his deliverables and of their commercial and operational significance.
  • From individual delivery to end-to-end ownershipPreviously, once his part of a project was finished, his responsibility was effectively over. We looked at ownership through a wider lens: what exactly have you delivered, where does it sit in the wider project, what is the current status and what still needs attention? He began tracking his contributions beyond his own work through structured emails and updates, explaining what he had done, what it had become and where it stood.
  • Confidence to ask questions in leadership conversationsHe held back in discussions, worried that asking a question would make him look stupid. We used a Listen → Curiosity → Question approach: listen carefully and understand the context instead of preparing your next statement; identify what is unclear, missing or worth exploring; and ask because you genuinely want to understand. We practised open and closed question formats on real-world scenarios such as vague problems and estimation-type questions.

The turning point: the seven-day challenge

Even after practice he found it very hard to apply the approach in meetings. He described his heartbeat speeding up and imagining people laughing at or judging his question. I pointed out that he had never actually asked, so he had no evidence the reaction he feared would happen - and that people might well appreciate the question.

Instead of more exercises, I gave him a practical assignment: ask at least one genuinely curious question every day. Positive responses built his confidence and gradually stopped him holding back because of imagined judgement. His questions began to affect others too; he reported colleagues telling him:

  • "Because of you, I started thinking differently. Thanks for the question."

The outcome: visibility, recognition and a better appraisal rating

As he applied these changes, the way people interacted with him shifted. Team members began seeking his opinion on business impact, and he became more confident asking questions and stating his own view.

There was also measurable appraisal movement. His ratings had typically been in the 2–3 range; in the following quarter he received a 4, along with very positive feedback from colleagues about the value he added.

Outcome basis: Appraisal rating and colleague feedback as reported by the client to REY.

In the client's words

I worked with Dinesh at a time when I needed a lot more clarity around decisions, priorities, and execution, and his ability to cut through the noise was immediately apparent.

He has a first-principles approach to thinking. Rather than giving you the usual generic advice, he asks the right questions and challenges assumptions. He is very good at getting to the root of a complex situation with multiple variables at play.

Coming from an investment banking and equity research background, I really do prize clear thinking, logical frameworks, and decision discipline, and Dinesh certainly had all three.

I have no doubt that Dinesh is operating at a level that supports senior-level responsibility and leadership, and I would certainly recommend him for promotion and appraisal.

Siddharth Gupta, LinkedIn recommendation, 29 January 2026

The larger lesson: executive presence is more than speaking confidently

Executive presence is often equated with confident speaking, polished presentation and an authoritative manner. At senior levels it is about understanding the business, taking ownership, communicating outcomes, asking the right questions and shifting how people think.

Being responsible for delivering the work is not the same as making its value visible to leadership. When you understand and can articulate the commercial impact of what you do, you are far better placed to join the strategic conversation.

Your work shouldn't have to speak for itself. You need to know how to communicate what you have achieved.

Related coaching service

Executive presence coaching →

Leadership visibility, strategic communication and presence in senior rooms.

Facing a similar decision?

Talk it through privately with Dinesh. Your context will differ; the conversation starts there.

All client transformations →